May 2, 2024
Current Year Results
Results Search
Biggest/Best Boston Qualifier
2024 Results
2023 Results
2022 Results
2021 Results
2020 Results
2019 Results
2018 Results
2017 Results
2016 Results
2015 Results
2014 Results
2013 Results
2012 Results
2011 Results
2010 Results
2009 Results
2008 Results
2007 Results
2006 Results
2005 Results
2004 Results
2003 Results
2002 Results
2001 Results
2000 Results
☰
Eisenbahn Marathon Runner Comments
Back to Eisenbahn Marathon Information & Reviews
Course 4.2 
Organization 4.1 
Spectators 3.2
Number of comments: 20 [displaying comments 11 to 20]
|
L. W. from Evanston, IL
(6/11/2012)
 "Loved this marathon!" (about: 2012)
6-10 previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 5 ORGANIZATION: 5 FANS: 5 As someone who has done the Chicago Marathon numerous times, the Eisenbahn Marathon was like a breath of fresh air. The course was very scenic, especially when out on the rural roads. The limestone trail was a nice change from the constant pounding of concrete. Sure, there weren't many spectators, but there is something to be said about enjoying the peacefulness of the horse and cow pastures and the energy of the volunteers at the water stops was always something to look forward to. I would get an extra spring in my step when I could see them off in the distance. I liked the variety of flat trail and hilly roads, with most of the course being trail. The buses in the morning got us to the start without a problem. Plenty of Port-o-lets along the route. I was nervous about this race based on past year reviews but I think the organizers really improved everything that has been criticized in the past. I would definitely do this race again. | |
|
R. F. from Luxemburg, WI
(10/26/2011)
 "Good Idea- Poor Organization" (about: 2011)
50+ previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 4 ORGANIZATION: 3 FANS: 3 Unfortunately, our bus driver got lost driving to the starting line, causing lots of anxiety among many of the marathon runners. When we did arrive, there was too few port-o-potties, causing lots of anxiety among many of the marathon runners. There was also no water at the start, which would have been nice. The start of the marathon was delayed, due to the port-o-potties issue, causing even more anxiety among the marathon runners, especially with those having scheduled airline flights later in the day based on the original start time. Once the race got underway, things kind of smoothed out. The aid stations could have been better organized and uniformed in their delivery, you never knew which side (left, front, back, right) water or aid would be on... Plus the cups were too small. You had to grab two cups for one cup of water. The finish line was ok. The medal really was terrible. The shirt was ugly. The medical support was great throughout the race. Saw lots of people wearing red crosses. Planning and execution was very weak. Will not do next year. | |
|
B. K. from Home of the Reds and the hopeless Bengals
(8/29/2011)
 "Just you, the cornfields, and the grasshoppers" (about: 2011)
11-50 previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 2 ORGANIZATION: 1 FANS: 1 I don't like to leave negative comments about a marathon since, as a former race director, I know the work thats required. However this one had some serious defects. First, the marathon director delayed the start by nearly 20 minutes so that everyone could use the portalets. On a hot day with the heat index into the 80s, that endangers the five and six hour marathoners. I saw the ambulance taking someone away. Maybe more. They said there were 200 marathoners but only 172 finished. There are very few valid excuses for a late start. Second, a race official told us that GU would be provided at mile 11 or 12. There was none until mile 19. I will never place trust in gel placements in small marathons again. My friend and I, along with many others, ran on fumes. Local county government people apparently are in charge of this marathon. I don't know if any of them have run many marathons but I would strongly suggest that they enlist the help of a runners' store or runners' club in nearby Milwaukee for help. Otherwise this race will probably die a slow death. The negatives: 1. Start delayed 20 minutes 2. Gels promised at mile 12 didn't appear until mile 19 3. At one intersection, no arrows or volunteers to indicated course route. No traffic control for later runners, as my friend explained. 4. Post race food very lame: sliced oranges and pretzels. 5. Medal also lame: please put the name of the marathon on the front of the medal! 6. Crushed limestone trail was harder than concrete 7. Trail had gravel in some places with stones. This came early when the trail was crowded; so you had to be careful not to trip. 8. Trail mostly exposed to the sun on this hot day. Some patches of shade. 9. Very few watched along the route. One home taped off their front lawn so that runners would not step foot on it. Never seen that before. It was almost as if no one knew about the marathon or, if they did, didn't want us there. The positives: 1. Volunteers were wonderful 2. Tech shirt OK, but needs help in design. Tap into some of those talented high schoolers. 3. German festival in town was nice 4. Hampton Inn was excellent in all regards 5. Janulis (pasta dinner) and Grasshopper (post race dinner) - delightful | |
|
J. K. from Grayslake, IL
(8/29/2011)
"Second year fixed a few things - not all" (about: 2011)
50+ previous marathons
| 2 Eisenbahn Marathons
COURSE: 4 ORGANIZATION: 4 FANS: 3 This was the second year of this event and they fixed some things from last year, but there are still areas for improvement. First they corrected the mile markers - they were spot on, thanks. Second, they had more buses so everyone fit without standing. You may wonder why you need to board the buses at 4:45am for a maximum 26 mile ride to the 6:00am start....it is because for the 2nd year in a row some buses got lost! Unbelievable. Then we had to start 20 minutes late - which allowed the temperatures to climb. The other issue I encountered was an unmanned cross road where myself and another runner had a close encounter with a truck. He slammed on his brakes when we 'popped' out on the road - very dangerous. The cross road was 'Century'. Last little nit - for a hot August marathon, you need bigger cups at the water stops. Still looking forward to running this next year. | |
|
C. S. from Springfield, Illinois USA
(8/28/2011)
"This is a hard race to rate, but here goes" (about: 2011)
50+ previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 4 ORGANIZATION: 2 FANS: 5 This race is tough to critique, because the things the organizers did well, they did VERY WELL, but the items where they had trouble, they had a LOT of trouble. First, the POSITIVES - packet pickup was smooth and organized - the talk was good - water stops were superb and organized, workers enthusiastic and helpful. Some great costumes - as the weather warmed up, having the girl roving on the ATV offering drinks between the water stops was an excellent idea - finish line was organized and efficient. I didn't have any medical issues, but it looked like there were quite a few who did, and EMS was on top of it(VERY GOOD THING) Areas of NEEDED IMPROVEMENT: - Most of All, TELL THE BUS DRIVERS WHERE WE ARE GOING!! At least 2 buses got lost again this year. I drove to and from the start line the day before the race, using two good, direct routes. I didn't know where I was going, and didn't get lost. No excuse for this, seriously!! We still got to the start area 30 minutes before the start, tho - this race started 20 minutes late. Part of the reason may have been that there were only 5 porta-potties for at least 200 people (admittedly I don't know what the ratio should be). Having the building near the start line open would probably provide more toilets at minimal cost. Another cause of the delay may be that the organizers are very nice people, trying to please the most amount of people - When we got to the Hampton Inn, they first told us they couldn't give us a late checkout because a wedding party was checking in the next day. The clerks also told us they JUST FOUND OUT this was the official race hotel, and weren't going to put out breakfast early. Next year, negotiate a 4am breakfast, and 1pm late checkouts - let runners know the YMCA closes at noon, for those who want to take advantage of the shower facilities. Although I finished under 4:40, I didn't hurry to shower: the guy at the desk told a couple of us that the Y closed at 12 and we had 1 minute to get into the shower. Communication easily solves this one I'm sorry if this seems too negative, but I prefer to offer solutions when I offer criticism. From the moment the race actually started, to the moment it ended, the experience was positive. Just need to tweak some of the logistical things. | |
|
L. M. from Madison, WI
(10/24/2010)
"Good inaugural race, but not a "must do"" (about: 2010)
50+ previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 3 ORGANIZATION: 4 FANS: 3 The organization of this race was good for an inaugural year. Plenty of porta-potties and aid stations (with ice - key for an August marathon in Wisconsin), and packet pick up was easy. And I always have to thank the friendly volunteers. The main issue that I saw was a lack of communication with the buses to the start. I got to the bus area plenty early, but it appeared that they didn't have enough buses for the runners. It was standing room only in the aisle, not ideal for a 26-mile, jarring school bus ride before the marathon. Also, after both buses were full to capacity, they said we are full and shut the doors to the couple people who still weren't on the bus yet. I don't know if those people ever got to the start or not. My bus driver didn't know the exact location or the route to the start line, and ended up making a wrong turn (after getting bum directions from a different bus driver over the radio) and had to be directed by a local runner on how to get to the course. Our bouncy bus ride was probably at least 10 minutes longer due to the impromptu detour. As for the course, I generally like Wisconsin railroad bed trails, but this one is my least favorite section of trail. The trail is lined with scrub trees and bushes for the most part - not tall enough to provide good shade, but dense enough to totally block the view. The course is shaded early on, but if you are a greater-than 4-hour marathoner, you will probably have a couple hours of full sun. The best part of the course was when it left the trail and went on country roads for a couple miles. Yes, this added some pretty serious hills to the race (which I like to change the muscle use), but the countryside scenery on this section was much better. The medal and t-shirt were unremarkable and boring. I'd suggest that they integrate the Germanfest theme (running in West Bend that weekend), or some other Wisconsin-oriented theme for the shirt design and medal. The best part of this race was the shower at the YMCA afterward. Hands down, this was the nicest post-race shower facility that I have used to date. | |
|
E. S. from Montrose, Michigan
(9/2/2010)
 "Great country setting" (about: 2010)
11-50 previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 4 ORGANIZATION: 4 FANS: 1 I planned this marathon around a motorcycle vacation with my husband and to knock off the state of Wisconsin in my quest to run a marathon in very state of America. I loved the 6 a.m. start, the solitude of the trail, the limestone terrain, the cheery and enthusiastic volunteers at the aid stations, the plentiful water, the refreshing ice and sprinklers toward the end, the police blocking the roads, and the beautiful setting in the quaint German festival town of West Bend. Tech shirt was nice, although it did not have the marathon name on it, and I wish the medal had more of a Wisconsin cheese or trail theme on it or the neck band to represent the state. And a big thank you to the YMCA for the wonderful shower, warm towels and changing accommodations at the end. I felt I was in a top-notch hotel!! Great job!! | |
|
J. K. from Grayslake, IL
(8/31/2010)
"Overall, a well-run marathon" (about: 2010)
50+ previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 4 ORGANIZATION: 4 FANS: 3 First-year marathons always have their challenges, but I would say the race organizers did a very good job. The buses to the start were a little overcrowded but that gave you time to meet your fellow runners. I also suspect that the mile markers were slightly off as my times bounced from fast/slow on the miles - someone with a GPS could verify. The hills were indeed larger than I expected but they added some variety to the otherwise flat, straight course (thankfully, they were on the front half). I would definitely do this race again. | |
|
M. D. from Lake Oconne, GA
(8/31/2010)
 "Excellent inaugural race." (about: 2010)
11-50 previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 5 ORGANIZATION: 5 FANS: 2 This is a good race with a lot of potential. The course is very lovely with just enough hills to make it interesting. The support staff were outstanding. This is certainly worthy of consideration if you like small, efficient races. | |
|
J. B. from Austin, TX
(8/29/2010)
"Inaugural Eisenbahn" (about: 2010)
11-50 previous marathons
| 1 Eisenbahn Marathon
COURSE: 4 ORGANIZATION: 5 FANS: 3 This marathon was very well done. Even though this was its first year, it's obvious these folks know what they're doing. The course is almost all on a converted railbed. The surface is crushed limestone (small, like pea-sized gravel, and pretty well packed). There is ample shade. It is super flat with the exception of the two times you leave the course and head out on county roads. The first time, around mile five, has a couple of big climbs. The second time, around mile 11, has some pretty good rollers. When you're on the railbed, it is just plain flat. The elevation chart off my Garmin shows it being net downhill, but you won't think so when you're running it. Once you get close to town, the railbed is paved with asphalt so you know you're almost there. If you're looking for Wisconsin as one of your 50 states or just want a nice summer marathon... give Eisenbahn a try! |
© 2000-2024, All Rights Reserved by MarathonGuide.com LLC
